All comparisons
VS

Fideliya: Digital Stamp Card vs Paper Card

Claus Haus's loyalty pass in Google Wallet
Claus Haus's loyalty pass in Apple Wallet
Real passes, made in Fideliya.

Fideliya turns your paper punch card into a stamp card that lives in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, so it cannot be lost, washed, forgotten or forged, and every stamp is logged against a named customer. Paper cannot show you who your regulars are, cannot message them, and can be copied with a stamp from a stationery shop. Subway ended its Sub Club stamp program in 2005 after counterfeit stamps were sold on online auction sites, as the Associated Press reported on 2 June 2005, and relaunched it digitally in December 2025. Fideliya is free for up to 20 customers and runs stamps, points, referrals and gift cards on one platform.

Fideliya keeps everything your customers like about the paper stamp card and removes the three things that break it. The card sits in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet so it cannot be lost or washed, every stamp is logged against a named customer so it cannot be quietly forged, and you finally see where each customer stands instead of their visits vanishing into a pocket. Fideliya starts free for 20 customers, ships 36 designed pass themes with eighteen on the free plan, adds points, referrals and gift cards when the program outgrows stamps, and runs in English, French, Spanish, Italian and Arabic with full right-to-left support.

Updated October 23, 2026

A paper stamp card turns into the same card as a pass in Apple Wallet.

Feature Comparison

FeatureFideliyaPaper Stamp Cards
Where the card livesApple Wallet and Google Wallet, already on the phoneA paper card in a pocket, bag or drawer
Can be lost, washed or forgottenNoYes
Can be forged or self-stampedNo, every stamp is logged against a named customerYes, a stationery-shop stamp is enough
Customer dataVisit history, frequency and gaps per customerNone
Reaching customersLock screen messages through the walletNot possible
Reward mechanicsStamps, points, referrals, gift cardsStamps only
Cost to start€0 on the free plan, up to 20 customersPrinting, and reprinting
More than one locationOne program across every locationCards do not transfer between shops
Card design36 designed themes, 18 on the free plan, logo, cover image on ProWhatever the print shop offers
Languages5 (EN/FR/ES/IT/AR), right-to-left supportedOne per print run
  • Where the card lives

    Fideliya
    Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, already on the phone
    Paper Stamp Cards
    A paper card in a pocket, bag or drawer
  • Can be lost, washed or forgotten

    Fideliya
    No
    Paper Stamp Cards
    Yes
  • Can be forged or self-stamped

    Fideliya
    No, every stamp is logged against a named customer
    Paper Stamp Cards
    Yes, a stationery-shop stamp is enough
  • Customer data

    Fideliya
    Visit history, frequency and gaps per customer
    Paper Stamp Cards
    None
  • Reaching customers

    Fideliya
    Lock screen messages through the wallet
    Paper Stamp Cards
    Not possible
  • Reward mechanics

    Fideliya
    Stamps, points, referrals, gift cards
    Paper Stamp Cards
    Stamps only
  • Cost to start

    Fideliya
    €0 on the free plan, up to 20 customers
    Paper Stamp Cards
    Printing, and reprinting
  • More than one location

    Fideliya
    One program across every location
    Paper Stamp Cards
    Cards do not transfer between shops
  • Card design

    Fideliya
    36 designed themes, 18 on the free plan, logo, cover image on Pro
    Paper Stamp Cards
    Whatever the print shop offers
  • Languages

    Fideliya
    5 (EN/FR/ES/IT/AR), right-to-left supported
    Paper Stamp Cards
    One per print run

Fideliya takes the paper punch card and puts it in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet. The mechanic does not change: buy nine, get the tenth free. What changes is that the card cannot be lost, cannot be forged, and finally tells you something. Paper got the psychology right, which is why it has lasted forty years. It is the medium that fails, not the idea.

Why paper fails

A paper card has to survive a pocket, a bag, a wash cycle and the customer remembering to bring it. When it does not, the customer loses their progress, and losing progress is more discouraging than never starting.

It can also be copied. The most famous stamp card in the world was killed by exactly that. Subway ran its Sub Club from the 1980s: eight stamps for a six-inch sub, ninth free. On 2 June 2005 the Associated Press reported that Subway was ending the program, because counterfeit stamps and pre-filled cards were being sold on online auction sites and franchisees were increasingly finding fakes among their redemptions. It was phased out company-wide by that October. Subway brought Sub Club back in December 2025, and it came back digital.

The most successful stamp card ever run was destroyed by paper, and returned twenty years later as software.

What a Fideliya card does instead

Every stamp is logged against a named customer with a timestamp, so nobody adds one without a scan. The card sits in the wallet next to boarding passes and bank cards, updates in real time at the counter, and cannot be left at home. Staff scan from a browser, so there is nothing to install on the counter device.

The part paper never offered is visibility. Fideliya shows you visit history per customer, how often each one comes in, and who has quietly stopped. That is the difference between running a loyalty program and hoping one is working.

What the card looks like

Fideliya ships 36 designed pass themes with eighteen on the free plan, each built as a color set rather than assembled from a picker, with your logo on every one and cover images on Pro. A paper card is whatever the print shop offers, reprinted every time you change anything.

Making the switch

Run both for the first month. Put a QR code on the counter tent, train staff with one sentence, and honor the count on any existing paper card when its holder enrolls so nobody loses progress. By the second month most enrollments will be digital.

Fideliya also grows past stamps when the program is ready: points for customers who spend more per visit, referrals for regulars who bring friends, and gift cards for December. Same platform, same customers, no second migration.

The method, step by step, with what your team says at the counter: how to switch without losing a single stamp.

What it costs

Fideliya is free for 20 customers with stamps or points, wallet passes included, eighteen themes and a campaign a month. Pro at €49.99 raises that to 2,500 customers, the remaining eighteen themes, cover images, gift cards, the referral program, CSV export and five team seats. Paper costs you a reprint every time anything changes, and it never returns any data at all.

Simple, transparent pricing

Turn visitors into regulars. Start free.

  • Free

    €0.00/ month

    1 business · 1 active pass · 20 customers

  • Pro

    €49.99/ month

    1 business · 1 active pass · 2,500 customers · 4 locations

  • Enterprise

    €99.99/ month

    1 business included, up to 5 · 1 active pass each · Unlimited customers · Unlimited locations

  • No credit card required
  • Cancel anytime
Compare plans

Frequently asked questions

  • For most businesses, yes. A Fideliya stamp card does everything a paper card does and then three things paper cannot: it lives in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet so it cannot be lost or washed, it lets you message customers on their lock screen, and it shows you who your regulars are and how often they visit. A Fideliya card takes about five minutes to set up.

  • No. A Fideliya card is added to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, which are already on every phone, so there is nothing to download and no account to create. The customer scans a QR code once and the card saves to their phone, then updates itself each time staff scan it at the counter.

  • No. Every Fideliya stamp is logged against a named customer with a timestamp, so a stamp cannot be added without a scan. Paper is a different story: Subway ended its Sub Club stamp program in 2005 after counterfeit stamps and filled cards were sold on online auction sites, as the Associated Press reported on 2 June 2005. Subway brought the program back in December 2025, digitally.

  • Put a Fideliya QR code on the counter and run both for the first month. Staff need one sentence: our card goes straight to your phone. Existing paper cardholders carry over because you honor the count on their old card when they enroll, so nobody loses progress. After the first month most enrollments will be digital and the paper can go.

  • Fideliya is free for up to 20 customers, with wallet passes included, eighteen designed pass themes and either a stamp card or a points program. Pro is €49.99 a month for 2,500 customers, gift cards, the referral program, cover images, CSV export and five team seats. Paper looks cheap until you count reprinting.

  • Yes. A Fideliya pass sends messages that land on the customer lock screen through Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, so you can reach someone who has not visited in a few weeks or tell regulars about a quiet Tuesday. Paper has no way to do this at all. Free plans include one campaign a month and Pro includes three.

  • Yes. Fideliya issues an Apple Wallet pass and a Google Wallet pass from the same program, so each customer gets the right one automatically and you run a single stamp card across both.

  • There is none, which is the quiet cost of paper. A paper card cannot tell you who came in, how often, or who has stopped coming. Fideliya records every scan against a named customer, so you can see visit frequency, spot regulars who are slipping, and export the whole list as CSV on Pro at €49.99 a month.

Ready to get started?

No card. If your regulars don't join, you pay nothing.

See a pass in your wallet in ten seconds

Ask your AI about us

Add to Apple WalletAdd to Google Wallet
© 2026 Fideliya. All rights reserved.
Fideliya: Digital Stamp Card vs Paper Card | Fideliya